On a recent flight, I picked up Caroline Elkins’ 2005 book, Imperial Reckoning: The Untold Story of Britain’s Gulag in Kenya, to keep me company during the many hours of travel home. As I research the religious dimensions of the British Empire for my next book, The Galilean Way, I have found Elkins’ account particularly illuminating. Her work confirms and deepens many of the arguments I made in Decolonizing Mission, especially concerning the ways in which Christian mission became entangled with the structures and imagination of empire.

In what follows, I will begin by sharing two substantial passages from Elkins’ book before reflecting on what reading her work has led me to consider in relation to the new imagination of mission I am proposing in The Galilean Way.
The missionaries had a leading role in Britain’s civilizing mission in Kenya, as they did throughout the empire. Missionaries were determined to convert the Africans not just to Christianity but to an entire Western way of life. They competed with one another for African souls, with each denomination carving out its own spheres throughout Britain’s colonies. In the Kikuyu reserves, the Presbyterians, the Anglicans, the Methodists, and the Catholics dominated the Christian scene, establishing mission stations—which included churches, schools, and medical clinics—condemning the heathenism of Kikuyu religious and cultural practices, and preaching the values of Christianity, commerce, and civilization. For the colonial government, missionaries offered civilization on the cheap. (loc 68/1339).
Before discussing the missionaries’ role in the British colonial project, Elkins spent another long paragraph on the paternalistic ideologies that made the empire happen.
[The colonial project] was predicated on a sense of entitlement that resulted not only from the shared aristocratic pedigree of many British immigrants but also from a perception of profound racial superiority that infused every rung of the colony’s white socioeconomic ladder. By virtue of their skin colour, whites of all classes were the master race and therefore deserving privilege. To the settlers, there was nothing noble about the African “savage.” Many believed the African to be inferior, with a smaller brain size, a limited capacity to feel pain or emotion, and even different nutritional needs, requiring only a bowl of maize meal, or posho, to maintain their health. African men had to be controlled; they were unpredictable and sexually aggressive, threatening both white women and the maintenance of their idealised chastity as well as the racial purity of the colony’s European community. Virulent racist ideologies grew more intense over time as the so-callednative was moved along the racist spectrum from stupid, inferior, lazy, and childlike to savage, barbaric, atavistic, and animal-like (loc 50/1339).
It is this issue of paternalism in mission that has been on my mind as I am writing The Galilean Way.
When we talk about colonialism and mission, people want an example of how this happens today. I think one of the ways it happens is in the continuing paternalising attitudes and practices in mission. Paternalism continues in mission today, in most cases, without needing to disguise itself.
Is mission possible without paternalism?
Paternalism is central to the colonising project. Colonialism did not operate only through conquest, violence and economic exploitation; it was also sustained by a particular moral imagination in which some peoples were positioned as more mature, more civilised, more knowledgeable and more capable than others. The coloniser could therefore present domination as benevolence. The language was often one of care, education, development and improvement: we know what is best for you, and we have come to help you become what you ought to be. Paternalism made unequal relationships appear natural, necessary and even virtuous.
This paternalism is also central to a great deal of the current imagination and practice of Christian mission. We may have become much more sophisticated in our language. We speak of partnership, empowerment, capacity building, leadership development and mutuality. Yet beneath some of these models remains an older assumption: that the missionary is the one who possesses something that the other lacks. We have the resources; they have the need. We have the expertise; they need training. We have the theological knowledge; they need formation. We know how mission works; they need to learn how to do it.
The problem is therefore deeper than the question of who is doing the mission. It concerns the relational imagination of mission itself. We can change the missionary, change the geography and change the direction of missionary movement while leaving the underlying relationship untouched. A Western missionary going to Africa can be paternalistic. But so can an African missionary going to Europe. An African Christian arriving in Europe can unconsciously assume that Europeans need to be evangelised, discipled or corrected in ways that reproduce precisely the relationship that African Christians have rightly criticised when it has been imposed upon them by Western missionaries.
This is an important challenge for those of us committed to decolonising mission. We cannot assume that changing who occupies the missionary role automatically decolonises the missionary relationship. If an African missionary goes to Europe believing, “We have what you need, and we have come to give it to you,” the direction of mission may have changed, but paternalism remains. The passport has changed. The colour of the missionary has changed. The geographical flow has changed. But the missionary imagination has not.
This is why I increasingly think that decolonising mission requires us to imagine mission without paternalism. We need to ask not simply who should lead, who should send, or who should receive, but what kind of relationship mission creates between people. What happens when we stop imagining the missionary as the person who arrives with the answers and begin to imagine the missionary as someone who enters a context in which God is already at work?
This does not mean that missionaries have nothing to offer. It does not mean that we abandon proclamation, teaching, leadership or service. Nor does it require us to pretend that all people possess the same gifts, knowledge or resources. Mutuality does not mean sameness. It means that difference does not automatically become hierarchy. I may have something that you need, while you have something that I need. I may bring theological training, while you bring wisdom formed through a particular history of Christian faithfulness. I may have financial resources, while you possess contextual knowledge without which those resources can easily become destructive. We both arrive with gifts, and we both arrive with limitations.
The question therefore shifts from “What do these people need from us?” to “What is God already doing here, and how might we participate in it together?” That is a significant missiological shift. It moves us from the missionary as provider to the missionary as participant. It moves us from development to discernment, from dependency to mutuality, from control to shared participation.
Perhaps this is especially important as African Christianity increasingly becomes a missionary presence in Europe. African Christians in Europe are not simply migrants who need to be integrated into European Christianity. They are also missionaries, theologians, church planters and agents of God’s mission. But their missionary vocation does not require Europeans to become African. The challenge is to resist the temptation to reproduce the very logic we are trying to leave behind: we have discovered the right way of being Christian, and now we have come to show you.
The same principle applies in the other direction. Western Christians going to Africa cannot assume that their knowledge, resources or institutional models make them the mature partner in the relationship. African Christians do not need to become dependent recipients of Western mission. But neither do Western Christians need to disappear from the story. The goal is something more demanding: a relationship in which neither side occupies the position of the one who knows best.
This is where I think the future of mission needs to go. We need models of mission in which people can bring their gifts without turning those gifts into claims of superiority; in which leadership can be exercised without domination; in which resources can be shared without creating dependency; and in which theological knowledge can be exchanged rather than monopolised. We need to move from power over to power with, and from being the people who have the answers to becoming communities capable of discerning together.
If paternalism was one of the relational logics through which colonial Christianity operated, then decolonising mission cannot simply mean replacing Western missionaries with missionaries from elsewhere. It must involve a deeper transformation of the relationship itself. Otherwise, we risk creating a new missionary geography while reproducing an old missionary imagination.
The question for the future, then, is not simply who will be the missionaries? It is what kind of people will missionaries be in relation to those among whom they serve? Perhaps the missionary vocation of the future will require us to become less concerned with being needed and more willing to participate in what God is already doing. Less concerned with bringing people to our centre and more willing to discover Christ already present beyond it.
This is what I mean by mission without paternalism. It is not mission without leadership, mission without proclamation, or mission without conviction. It is mission without the assumption that one person, culture or tradition must occupy the position of the parent while another remains the child.
And perhaps that is one of the most important tasks of decolonising mission: not simply changing who carries the gospel, but changing the kind of relationship through which the gospel is carried.


Thank you for articulating this so clearly. I have worked for our denominational agency, and there was always an uncomfortable dynamic at work that was hard to name. It was often noticed most around finances, but I can see the root so much more clearly now. Sadly, the stories of those who grew up under the leadership of missionaries. Illustrate the power-over instead of power-with model that was (and often still is) normalized. I’m glad for those to see it now, but sad for the ones who have stepped out because that model has been perpetuated in the local leadership.
This essay is very insightful. You put into words what I have long felt and seen. We do need a new missiological imagination. I’m excited for your next book. Thank you for the care with which you study and write. It is a blessing for all who read and engage in these critically important issues.